27348 Wharram (commentary) Could this paradise really be poor, desperate Haiti? (fwd)

[Bob Corbett <corbetre@webster.edu>]

Bruce Wharram <bruce.wharram@sev.org>

	The Christian Science Monitor - csmonitor.com

from the January 25, 2006 edition -
http://www.csmonitor.com/2006/0125/p01s02-woam.html

Could this paradise really be poor, desperate Haiti?
By Danna Harman | Staff writer of The Christian Science Monitor

LABADEE, HAITI - It has mango and almond trees, soft white sand, turquoise
waters, and a perfect breeze. It looks like a secret paradise island. It
feels like a secret paradise island.

But, actually, it's Haiti, the poorest country in the hemisphere.

Every week, up to 7,000 camcorder-toting tourists, the vast majority of them
Americans, come ashore here off a Royal Caribbean cruise ship for a day of
sun, sailing, volleyball tournaments, and sliding on the "world's largest"
inflatable water slide.

"It's the best kept secret in the world," says Melody Hickey, from Columbus,
Ohio. "Its amazing."

Haiti - usually known for its poverty and political instability - is not a
typical holiday destination for the bikini-clad set.

But Labadee seems a world away.

In fact, as far as many of the tourists are concerned, Labadee actually is
in a different part of the world.

"Isn't Puerto Rico part of Haiti?" asks a high school senior from Nashville,
Mich., getting off the ship to get her hair braided.

"I thought we were coming to a place called Hispaniola," says Cindy Roberts
from Madison, Ind., as she bargains for a voodoo bottle at the 'Native
Market' set up for tourists. "But I guess it doesn't matter," she says. "So,
it's Haiti."

The tourists have a good excuse for their confusion. "Welcome to Labadee!"
reads the banner - emblazoned with the face of a Johnny Depp look-alike
pirate - strung up on the pier.

A small wooden sign facing away from the incoming crowds reads "Labadee,
Haiti." Most, however, just pass it by in the rush to the Ben & Jerry's ice
cream stand.

The interactive TV monitors in the onboard cabins show the ship moving
across the ocean to an Island clearly marked Haiti. But, the Royal
Caribbean's website mystifies the bay as a "private," and "secret"
destination. When it is labeled, they call it "Labadee, Hispaniola," in
reference to the name given to the island by Christopher Columbus, who,
incidentally, thought he was in China when he dropped anchor here in 1492.

The cruise line doesn't go out of its way to clear up any confusion about
the actual location of its private beach.

"We make no pretense of where we are," says David Southby, Royal Caribbean's
site manager for Labadee. "The real question is 'Where is Haiti?' - and
'What is Haiti?' If you are honest, even if you tell them, most passengers
don't know where they are, usually."

And, referring to the island as Hispaniola and not Haiti, is merely a
marketing tool, wrote Craig Milan, a senior vice president at Royal
Caribbean, in an email exchange.

"It's much like we refer to our port in Bayonne, N.J., as Cape Liberty
Cruise Port," he says. "We were getting the same response about not calling
that port 'Bayonne Cruise Port.' "

"I used to be mad about the cruise line trying to mask the identity of
Haiti," says Jean Cyril Pressoir, author of the "Guides Panorama, Haiti"
tour books. "But now, I understand: We have an image problem and this is a
way to get people to give the country a chance. Fair enough. We really need
the tourists."

Since 1986, the Royal Caribbean line has provided the largest source of
tourism revenue to Haiti. The cruise company pays the Haitian government $6
per passenger and employs about 300 locals, including security guards, beach
monitors, waiters, cleaners, as well as some managers. Approximately 200
more locals find work here selling their wares, often at inflated prices, at
the market stalls, or by providing entertainment.

"They certainly could be doing more for the local economy," says Florence
Lelio Joseph, a travel agent in Haiti's capital, Port-au-Prince. She notes
that the foreign operators take most of the profits out of the Caribbean,
and import food and other supplies from elsewhere. But, she admits, in a
country where the only other visitors now are UN staff, aid workers, and
ex-pat Haitians visiting home, "everything is relative."

"It's not my favorite type of tourism, but I recognize that if we were
smarter, we'd have 10 Labadees across the country," says Mr. Pressoir.
"Better tourists enjoy the beach than nothing at all."

And the beach - 260 acres of land - is probably all that these tourists see.
Visitors - who are not issued Haitian visas or immigration cards - are not
allowed off the premises, except on group kayaking and jet ski excursions.
The US State Department doesn't officially object to the visits, despite a
travel warning, out since November, that says "due to the volatile security
situation," US citizens should avoid travel to Haiti altogether.

Greta Urnisk from Pensacola, Fla., has been on 10 cruises to Labadee.

Walking around the now-familiar site in a yellow bathing suit and a yellow
Royal Caribbean fanny pack, she admits she has never set a flip flop out of
the gated area. "What in the world would I want to find out in the
mountains?" she asks.

But there are other reactions, too. Ralph and Cathy Oats from Dallas, Texas,
first came to this beach last July, as part of a vacation cruise, and, like
many, admit they had no idea they were in Haiti.

But, jet skiing that day, a chance interaction with some locals got them
thinking. "The desperation we saw in the eyes of the very thin men paddling
their boats out to us to present their handmade trinkets for sale was an
impression that never left us," says Cathy.

So, in December, when they took a second cruise to Labadee, they came with
suitcases of toiletries and school supplies from their community to donate
to a private Canada-based charity, Hearts Together for Haiti. Started in
1996, the group operates schools, health clinics, and programs to provide
food to residents in the area. Royal Caribbean security helped transport the
donations to nearby Labadee village, a few coves away.

"It's easy to put down the cruise ships and say those folks are oblivious to
where they are and to the suffering around them," says Father John Duarte,
who runs Hearts Together. "But the important thing to do is encourage both
individuals and the Royal Caribbean management to understand the needs here
and work with us. Good can come of this."

Gito Roberts or, as he is known to friends, Ti Gito (little Gito), grew up
in Labadee village, and makes a living ferrying villagers back and forth to
coves along the shore in his cousin's skiff.

He sings jazz songs as he works, dreaming of some day going to New York to
hear his musical idols play.

"I would like to get on one of those big ships and see what America is
like," he says. He pulls down the donated Royal Caribbean baseball cap he,
like about half the villagers, sports: "... and then I would like to come
home immediately."

"All these tourists come here," he points out, "because they, who have seen
a lot, know that there is no lovelier place in the world than my country."

? Ms. Harman is Latin America correspondent for the Monitor and USA Today.

Full HTML version of this story which may include photos, graphics, and
related links

www.csmonitor.com | Copyright © 2006 The Christian Science Monitor. All
rights reserved.