[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

#899: Disruptions at election events, etc. (fwd)


Haiti123 shares views of people living and working in Haiti:

Basic question is who profits from these outbursts that have been seen at the 
two recent events.  What is the motive?  And who has what to gain from these 

There are many in the forefront, who are heavily funded and endorsed by 
foreigners, who are heavy handed in terms of influence and publicity -- but 
yet are without any base whatsoever and therefore have nothing to gain by 
holding free and fair democratic elections.  

These same folks spend all their time attacking Aristide as responsible for 
all evil in the universe and never talk about ways to resolve the crushing 
misery of the majority of the country.  At the same time, many of these same 
folks are the ones who participated in the preparation or maintenance of the 
coup d'etat.  

Just like in the late 80s regarding election time, foreign money has gone to 
propping up those best for the foreigners and little-nothing organizations 
were approached by the NED (in early 1999) (for example) to become political 
parties at their service.  So in this sense there is a general anger at the 
collusion once again in force to block the will of the people.

Now, capitalizing on that anger, it appears clear to many that some folks 
within the clique I have just described could profit well by portraying Fanmi 
Lavalas as anti-democratic and violent.

To the contrary, Fanmi Lavalas has been not just giving lip service to 
elections but has held departmental meetings throughout the country and is 
working very hard to prepare for their three-day congress in December. Their 
Aristide Foundation for Democracy newspaper, Dignity, is chocked full of news 
on the elections.  

All the messages coming out of their party are supportive of elections and 
urging rural and other folks to register to vote.  They have issued press 
releases and make strong statements condemning the violence. On the very day 
of the rally in Petit-Goave this weekend when the disruption broke out, 
Father Devalcin of Fanmi Lavalas predicted that Fanmi Lavalas would be blamed 
for the violence. He was clear in his interview that it was not Fanmi Lavalas 
but as many are alleging, a deliberate effort to discredit Fanmi Lavalas and 
to throw off the elections.

On the other hand, I saw the rally in Petit-Goave on the television and it 
was a small handful of people chanting for Aristide.  This is acceptable 
behavior in the US when a counter-demonstration appears to express its views. 
 Of course physical violence is another thing.  However, again, people are 
saying that they were not Fanmi Lavalas people but deliberate saboteurs. I 
would never condone the throwing of urine at people but to put things in 
perspective, a former MICIVIH person raised the question on the Corbett list 
about the atrocities committed under the coup and how does urine compare with 

And when they say Fanmi Lavalas people are disrupting the events, do they 
mean people?  Isn't that what they mean?  When most of the people are with 
Fanmi Lavalas doesn't that reference mean the people?  How much money are 
those other folks paying out to get people to attend their rallies when the 
overwhelming majority of the people are with Aristide?

These maneuvers are not in the interest of Fanmi Lavalas who by all surveys 
taken by anyone and everyone has the support of the majority of the 
population.  But when free and fair elections result in the putting aside of 
those folks who are in the spotlight right now, they will loose speed and 
funding and the potential to further secure power.  

Secondly, compounding the problem is the perception that the US is 
controlling the elections by its contract with the Canadian firm on the voter 
cards.  Many foreigners have asked me if the US is still controlling the 
elections because they heard about the direct contract.  I was surprised how 
this perception took hold so widespread.  Further, the perception that IFES 
controls the CEP reinforces the people's anxiety over elections that are not 
by them and not for them.

Repeatedly, I hear allegations of coup d'etat electoral alluding to how the 
elections are designed to block the people.

This has further shaken the confidence of the Haitian people and I believe 
those who are trying to destabilize the elections are capitalizing on this as 

In terms of motivation we have to ask ourselves why would Fanmi Lavalas do 
such things?  Would they want to discredit themselves?  Would they want to 
appear un-democratic?  Wouldn't they overwhelmingly win in free and fair 
elections?  This would give them the opportunity to gain seats in Parliament. 

Now, who doesn't want Fanmi Lavalas to have seats in Parliament?  Those 
concerned with privatization?  Those who want the army back?  Those in 
control of drug trafficking and money-laundering?  Those who control 

We have to look also at the whole picture which includes the Operation 
Columbus mission just completed here and the impending "pullout" of the US 
military.  Prior to every "pull out" there is a marked increase in violence 
and currently those same folks who so cleverly and with the help of the IRI 
and other such groups, have wangled a space for themselves, are calling for a 
US military intervention and demanding the resignation of President Preval.  
We hear those same Macoutes, like the MPSN, who carried out the coup for 
three years appealing for an intervention now!

[I was marveling this week at how those "political prisoners", like Claude 
Raymond, that had been in prison so long got so much international publicity 
and sympathy and yet, when they were plotting against the nation and killing 
people and picking off a new and young police force -- very few people 
outside Haiti seemed to care.]

Its all a grand act.  And Fanmi Lavalas is the scapegoat.  A list in a 
current article of La Reforme makes clear the amount of Fanmi Lavalas people 
recently assassinated.  Who is assassinating the Fanmi Lavalas people?  

The same sector who has carried out the repression against the people (of 
which Aristide is synonymous with) are the same now saying 'no to violence.'  
 This is a textbook case right out of the book about how the Contras built up 
their image. 

The timing is all so perfect.  All in the name of non-violence and democracy! 

Yesterday, there were many murders in Port-au-Prince!  All this to 
consolidate and strengthen their destabilization campaign while pinning 
everything on Fanmi Lavalas.  And surprise, surprise, mass repatriations of 
Haitians from the Dominican Republican!  Now, they are saying that the 
Dominican army is amassing at the border.  And doesn't that just feed into 
the call for the return of the Army?

Another view was a quote from a CEP member who suggested that disruption at 
the gym was sabotage planned by disgruntled CEP members!